DAP chairman Lim Guan Eng questioned the recent visit by a delegation from Afghanistan under the Taliban leadership to the Education Ministry.
He focused on the Taliban’s controversial restrictions on women’s education and asked why Malaysia was hosting a delegation from a country not officially recognised diplomatically. Guan Eng also raised concerns about the benefits – or lack thereof – of such a visit to Malaysia.
While these concerns are valid to some extent, is the reaction warranted? Couldn’t this visit represent a strategic opportunity for Malaysia to play a meaningful role in guiding Afghanistan towards positive change, particularly in terms of education and women’s rights?
Or is Guan Eng only seeing the risks without considering the diplomatic benefits? Malaysia’s decision to host the delegation does not mean formal recognition of the Taliban-led government.
Rather, it is an avenue to engage in dialogue and to send a strong message about Malaysia’s stance on inclusive education and women’s empowerment. Isn’t this a more constructive approach than isolation?
Diplomatically, this move is aligned with Malaysia’s potential to influence. Countries like China, Russia, and Pakistan have used dialogue and cooperation to steer Afghanistan towards rebuilding and stability.
‘Muslims must assist fellow Muslims’
As a respected Islamic nation, Malaysia can offer similar support while emphasising principles of inclusivity, human rights and education.
Criticising this engagement without acknowledging its diplomatic value could undermine Malaysia’s role as a proactive partner in global affairs.
Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek explained that the meeting discussed issues of education, including women’s access to it. Isn’t this consistent with Malaysia’s long-standing commitment to supporting progress in Muslim-majority nations?
It is important to recognise that Afghanistan is a country in need as it grapples with internal challenges after decades of conflict. As Muslims, the obligation to assist a fellow Muslim nation in their time of need is clear. Offering guidance through diplomacy is not only a strategic move but also a moral one.
Dialogue does not mean approval. It is a way to engage with problematic regimes to push for gradual reform and improvement.
Afghanistan’s record on women’s education is troubling but isolating them entirely will not lead to change. Malaysia’s engagement could instead be a means to advocate for human rights and inclusivity on a global stage.
Diplomacy is about creating pathways for long-term change. This visit, when viewed with the right perspective, is an opportunity for Malaysia to take the lead in addressing critical issues in Afghanistan.
It demonstrates Malaysia’s ability to uphold its principles while extending a hand to a struggling Muslim nation.
Isn’t it better to engage and influence rather than to disengage and criticise? This is a question worth reflecting on before jumping to conclusions. – Nov 21, 2024
Dr Mahathir Mohd Rais is the Perikatan Nasional (PN) Federal Territories’ state secretary.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Main image credit: Malaysiakini
