THE proposed new guidelines for ceremonies involving Muslims at non-Muslim houses of worship raises concerns about inclusivity, mutual respect and the principles of a harmonious multicultural society, warns Muhammad Shakir Ameer.
The Shah Alam City Council (MBSA) Councilor said while he understands the intention behind such guidelines – that is to ensure that Muslims do not compromise their faith – there are several issues that make these restrictions seem unnecessary and counterproductive.
“As a politically appointed Councilor in Shah Alam, the zone I represent consists of residents from various backgrounds,” he stated.
“The majority of events I attend or participate are community-centric programmes that also include various ethnic celebrations as well as a 174-year-old Hindu temple prayers event of which I sponsor refreshments and mobile toilets every year.”
Citing Malaysia’s identity as a diverse and multi-religious nation, Muhammad Shakir Ameer said placing restrictions on how Muslims engage in celebrations of other faiths could inadvertently foster division rather than protect religious integrity.
“Participating in a celebration does not mean endorsing another faith’s beliefs; rather, it signifies goodwill, respect, and appreciation of cultural diversity,” he stressed.
“Furthermore, the assumption that merely attending or participating in non-Islamic celebrations could weaken one’s Islamic faith underestimates the strength of personal belief and understanding.
“Faith is not so fragile that it can be compromised simply by celebrating with non-Muslims. Islam promotes critical thinking, tolerance and engagement rather than isolation.”
Muhammad Shakir further warned that guidelines imposing limitations on attending or participating in festivities such as Christmas, Deepavali or Chinese New Year can deepen misunderstandings between religious communities.
Such restrictions may alienate Muslims from their non-Muslim friends, colleagues, and neighbours, creating unnecessary tension rather than promoting peace and harmony, he added.
Rather than imposing restrictions, he pointed out that religious authorities should emphasise the difference between participation and religious endorsement.
“Attending a friend’s wedding, celebrating cultural aspects of a festival, or simply showing goodwill should not be seen as compromising one’s faith,” he reckoned.
“A better approach would be to educate Muslims on maintaining their religious identity while still being active and respectful members of a diverse society.”
It was reported yesterday (Feb 5) that the government is set to issue new guidelines for Muslim participation in non-Muslim celebrations and ceremonies.
According to Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Datuk Mohd Na’im Mokhtar, the guidelines will be finalised during the 126th Meeting of the Muzakarah Committee of the National Council for Islamic Religious Affairs Malaysia (MKI), scheduled to take place from Feb 25 to 27.
In a Parliamentary written reply, he also said another guideline will be issued, namely, ‘Guidelines on the participation of Muslims in celebrations and funeral ceremonies of Non-Muslims, as well as visits and the organisation of events in Non-Muslim houses of worship.’
Amid massive public backlash, Mohd Na’im said in a statement earlier today (Feb 6) that the proposed new guidelines are still under discussion with the authorities.
He also urged all parties to refrain from creating misunderstandings or polemics concerning the guidelines, which could result in public unrest. – Feb 6, 2025
Main image: Motorist Malaysia
