Are we seeing a replication of the Sabah state election in Melaka?

OVER a year ago, we were treated to a spectacle of political intrigue that could well have been the culmination of the Sheraton Move when the Sabah state government fell dramatically.

This saw 13 Sabah state assembly persons from Parti Warisan Sabah (Warisan) jumping ship and throwing their support behind former Sabah Chief Minister Tan Sri Musa Aman. 

In turn, Warisan president and then-Chief Minister Datuk Seri Panglima Shafie Apdal took the decisive step and pre-emptive strike by requesting Sabah governor Tun Juhar Mahiruddin to dissolve the Sabah state assembly immediately – thus triggering the Sabah state election on Sept 26, 2020. 

Slightly more than a year later, we now have the Melaka state election that was precipitated because the Melaka governor Tun Mohd Ali Rustam acquiesced to the advice of the caretaker government to dissolve the state assembly. 

Although there was no dissolution of the Melaka state assembly when two Pakatan Harapan (PH) assemblymen –DAP’s Datuk Norhizam Hassan Baktee and PKR’s Datuk Muhammad Jailani Khamis – shifted to Perikatan Nasional (PN) in March last year, the BN-led Melaka state government did not last long. 

Following the four state assemblymen – UMNO’s Datuk Seri Idris Haron and Datuk Nor Azman Hassan, Bersatu’s Datuk Noor Effandi Ahmad and (now) independent Datuk Norhizam – withdrawing their support for Chief Minister Datuk Seri Sulaiman Md Ali, the Melaka state assembly dissolved on Oct 4 with the polling day called on Nov 20. 

Despite there being no nine-cornered fights as is “customary” in Sabah state elections including the one last year, most Melaka state constituencies will still face three-cornered contests. 

A total of 112 candidates will contest in the Melaka state election.

Minor parties such as Parti Bumiputera Perkasa Malaysia (Putra) and Parti Perikatan India Muslim Nasional (Iman) will only contest five and one seats, respectively. 

There will be up to 22 independents throwing their hats into the ring as well. 

Intriguingly, as with the Sabah state election last year, BN and PN will still slug it out against each other in the Melaka state election. 

However, instead of clashing only in a proportion of state seats, BN and PN candidates will collide all the way despite being partners in government at the federal level. 

Out of the 28 seats from BN, 20 candidates are from UMNO, seven from the Malaysian Chinese Association (MCA) and one from the Malaysian Indian Congress (MIC). 

In contrast, PN comprises 15 seats from Bersatu, eight from PAS and five from Gerakan. 

For Pakatan Harapan (PH), PKR will field candidates in 11 seats, followed by nine from Amanah and eight from DAP. 


Strict COVID-19 SOPs in effect

However, unlike in the previous Sabah state election, political parties and candidates for the upcoming state election in Melaka are not allowed to organise any election-related gatherings, including house-to-house visits, walkabouts and ceramah as part of the Election Commission (EC)’s standard operating procedures (SOPs). 

Only three campaigners in a single team are allowed to go from house-to-house distributing campaign pamphlets without face-to-face interactions. 

Therefore, strict COVID-19 SOPs leave political parties and candidates with little room to “manoeuvre”. 

They could only maximise the deployment of social media platforms like Facebook, WhatsApp, Twitter and Youtube to reach out to their voters. 

BN and DAP volunteers drive trucks and lorries equipped with digital screens and loudspeakers around urban and rural Melaka to make campaign announcements. 

Even though the EC allows candidates and campaigners to put up buntings and banners before kickstarting their official campaigns starting from Nov 8, the desire for change that was palpable during the 14th General Election (GE14) had dissipated either due to fatigue or disillusionment. 

Like many Sabahans, Melakans appear to be more concerned about bread-and-butter issues such as cost of living, employment and income over who will form the next state government.

As both Melaka and Sabah are highly dependent on the tourism industry to generate state revenue, the on-and-off interstate travel ban and continuous closure of international borders for over two years have forced many businesses to shutter temporarily or permanently. 

Such a phenomenon is reflected particularly in the city centre of Kota Kinabalu and the popular Jonker Street in Melaka. 

The shutters were down for most of the sea and land tour agencies, and some even displayed signs that the shop lots were available for rent. 

The drastic fall of domestic tourists in both states between 2019 and 2020 has been accompanied by an increase in the absolute poverty rates of Melaka and Sabah of 2.2 and 5.8 percentage points in 2020, respectively.


The battle for state seats

During the previous GE14 and 2020 Sabah state elections, UMNO secured almost half (13 out of 28) of the Melaka state seats and around 44% (14 out of 32) of the Sabah state seats. 

On the other hand, Bersatu won one-third (2 out of 6) of the Melaka state seats when contesting under PH camp during GE14 in 2018. 

Despite Bersatu and UMNO fighting against each other in some state seats, Bersatu won more than half (11 out of 19) during the Sabah state election in 2020.

If the UMNO-led BN coalition and Bersatu-led PN coalition plans to form the Melaka state government together after the election, both have to win at least 15 state seats.

As for PH, top-performing DAP still has to rely on its coalition partners PKR and Amanah to win at least seven more seats in the Melaka state election.

During GE14 in 2018, DAP managed to win all 8 Melaka state seats. 

DAP also managed to win 6 out of 7 Sabah state seats during the 2020 Sabah state election. 

Notwithstanding, at the end of the day, it depends on how the coalition blocs and independent candidates run their online campaigns. 

The electoral participants will have to navigate through the landmine of hot issues and political fodder of the day such as the Melaka Waterfront Economic Zone (M-Wez). 

What is touted to be a gamechanger by the incumbent is opposed by the fishing community for loss of catch and environmental issues due to the land reclamation works. 

PN has pledged a thorough and comprehensive review of the mega project should it come into power. 

PH’s erstwhile Chief Minister Adly Zahari has also promised to do the same by giving special attention to all, as well as reclamation and sea embankment projects (as was done under his administration where the latter were halted).

Voter turnout will be crucial in determining the outcome of the Melaka state election. 

If the coalition blocs and independent candidates could motivate more voters coming out to vote through online campaigns, they could create history not only for the Melaka state election.

Such a new way of organising and conducting elections during pandemic times also could be applied to the upcoming Sarawak state election and 15th General Election (GE15) in the future. – Nov 17, 2021


Amanda Yeo is Research Analyst at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.

The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.

Subscribe and get top news delivered to your Inbox everyday for FREE