Editor’s Note: This is a more rational discourse coming from the opposition front in stark contrast from the call made by Bersatu Wanita chief Datuk Mas Ermieyati Samsudin who called for Youth and Sports Minister Hannah Yeoh to be removed from the Cabinet in light of the recent High Court decision in a defamation lawsuit filed by the latter against former IGP Tan Sri Musa Hassan.
MALAYSIA’S identity as a multi-cultural and multi-religious nation has always been its defining strength. However, balancing religious freedom and social harmony is never without challenges.
This is evident in the recent controversy involving Youth and Sports Minister Hannah Yeoh. After the High Court dismissed her defamation suit against former inspector-general of police (IGP) Tan Sri Musa Hassan, debates about her book “Becoming Hannah: A Personal Journey” and its perceived intentions have once again sparked public discussion.
While the concerns raised by Musa and others may warrant attention, it is crucial to respond thoughtfully and avoid over-reaction. As a country that upholds religious freedom under the Federal Constitution, Malaysia must handle such issues with care and fairness.
Yeoh’s decision to appeal the court ruling is well within her rights. In a functioning democracy, judicial processes exist precisely to address such disputes.
It is essential to allow the courts to carry out their role without interference or undue pressure. Accusations of evangelism and proselytization – as highlighted by critics – are serious allegations but they must be evaluated objectively within the legal framework.
Rushing to conclusions or making sweeping demands risks undermining the very principles of justice and fairness that our society upholds. If the law is to do its job, it must be given the space to function without the noise of public and political agitation.
“Ambassador of God” narrative
The term “Ambassador of God” as used by Yeoh in her book has drawn significant criticism. However, it is not uncommon for individuals of various faiths to view their roles as a calling or responsibility aligned with their beliefs.
Labelling her intentions as a direct threat to Islam or national unity requires substantial evidence beyond personal interpretations of her writings.
Malaysia is home to a significant population of Christian Malaysians, particularly in Sabah and Sarawak, who actively contribute to the nation’s progress.
Handling this situation with hostility risks alienating these communities and creating unnecessary divisions. Leaders must embody inclusivity, understanding and respect for all citizens regardless of their faith, to uphold Malaysia’s multi-cultural harmony.
Sensitive issues like these require rational and constructive dialogue. Bombarding individuals with accusations without fully understanding their intentions only fosters division and mistrust.
It is also essential to resist the politicisation of religion which often exacerbates tensions and distracts from more pressing national issues.
While I have disagreed with Yeoh on certain policy matters in the past, fairness and truthfulness must guide our responses. With the rakyat are watching, how this matter is handled will reflect the nation’s capacity to govern inclusively and rationally.
Extreme reactions serve nobody and would only undermine the pluralistic values upon which Malaysia was built.
The allegations against Yeoh highlight broader concerns about the inter-section of religion and politics.
If wrongdoing exists, it must be addressed through lawful channels without prejudice. However, this situation also underscores the importance of fostering unity and understanding among Malaysians of all backgrounds.
Leaders must rise above divisive rhetoric, focusing instead on the collective well-being of the nation.
Respecting the principles of justice and freedom of religion as guaranteed by the Constitution is paramount. Let the courts deliberate, let the facts speak and let Malaysia move forward with wisdom and unity.
In the end, we are all “ambassadors” of our respective faiths, entrusted to represent our beliefs in ways that build bridges, not walls. By embracing understanding and mutual respect, Malaysia will continue to thrive as a harmonious and inclusive nation. – Dec 28, 2024
Dr Mahathir Mohd Rais is the Perikatan Nasional (PN) Federal Territories state secretary.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
