MALAYSIA’S education system is confronting an uncomfortable contradiction. The number of students obtaining straight A’s in the Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia (SPM) examination has grown in recent years, and national examination results often appear encouraging.
Yet the country’s performance in international assessments tells a different story. In PISA 2025, Malaysia’s mathematics score fell further from 440 in 2018 to 397, with 65% of students failing to reach the baseline level of proficiency needed to apply mathematics to everyday situations.
This contrast between strong domestic results and weak international performance was highlighted by former minister Khairy Jamaluddin, who questioned whether Malaysia had allowed years of grade inflation to undermine the credibility of its SPM results.
His challenge deserves serious consideration. The question is whether the country has the courage to confront the problem.
Some argue that lenient grading is common in other countries and should not be treated as a crisis. But widespread practice does not make it acceptable.

Grade inflation has also become a concern in American universities, including Harvard, where efforts are under way to restore greater meaning to academic grades. Princeton University introduced a policy in 2004 to curb the proportion of A-range grades, only to abandon it in 2014.
These experiences show that reversing grade inflation is not straightforward. When too many students receive top grades, the distinction between good work and exceptional performance becomes increasingly blurred.
Malaysia’s problem, however, is not merely about examination scores. It reflects a system of distorted incentives.
When social mobility depends heavily on academic qualifications, and university admissions and recruitment place disproportionate weight on grades, examinations become a currency of survival rather than a measure of learning.
Teachers and schools face pressure to demonstrate good results, while administrators may judge performance through pass rates and examination outcomes. The temptation is to reward achievement on paper rather than confront weaknesses in understanding.
Students ultimately pay the price. Those who perform well in domestic examinations may discover that their ability to reproduce answers does not necessarily translate into applying knowledge to unfamiliar problems.
PISA tests precisely these skills, including the ability to interpret information, reason and solve practical problems. In Malaysia, only 0.6% of students reached the top two proficiency levels in mathematics in 2025, compared with an OECD average of 8%.
This is not evidence that Malaysian students lack ability. It raises serious questions about how effectively the education system develops and assesses that ability.
The answer is not simply to reduce the number of A grades. That risks creating fresh inequities without improving learning. Princeton’s experience is instructive: imposing numerical limits on top grades did not provide a lasting solution. Malaysia needs to address the incentives and practices behind its assessment system.
Three changes are essential.
First, transparency. The Ministry of Education should publish clear technical explanations of how examination standards are established and maintained.
The public should understand what an A grade represents and whether standards remain consistent between examination years. Independent academic scrutiny would help strengthen confidence in the results.
Second, more meaningful assessment. When a student’s future depends heavily on one standardised examination, teaching can become little more than preparation for predictable questions.
Malaysia’s experience with school-based assessment showed that changing the assessment method without adequately preparing teachers and providing resources can turn reform into a formality.

Teachers need sustained training and support to develop questions that test analysis, application and problem-solving, rather than recall alone.
Third, a broader measure of student ability. University admissions and recruitment should move beyond counting A grades. Academic results matter, but so do critical thinking, communication, creativity and practical skills.
A more comprehensive approach would recognise different strengths instead of treating one examination transcript as a complete measure of a person’s potential.
Education must prepare young people to think, judge and act in the real world, not merely produce impressive transcripts.
Malaysia cannot continue celebrating examination results while ignoring evidence that many students are struggling to apply what they have learnt.
It is time to stop fooling ourselves. Beautiful grades mean little if they conceal a failure to equip an entire generation with the knowledge and skills it needs. ‒ Nov 16, 2026
The author is affiliated with the Tan Sri Omar Centre for STI Policy Studies at UCSI University and is an Adjunct Professor at the Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies, Universiti Malaya.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Main image: Malay Mail




