MALAYSIANS should understand the background to the issue on the ban of the comic book which many could have forgotten. However, there are individuals and groups who are not willing to accept the federal court decision which has led the government lift the ban.
Background to this case
The case of Hew Kuan Yau’s comic book, Belt and Road Initiative for Win-Winism, is a significant example of how the Malaysian government responded to perceived political sensitivities related to China and domestic politics.
Hew, who is also known as “Superman Hew” is a DAP member and a strong supporter of China’s policies. He authored a comic book titled Belt and Road Initiative for Win-Winism, which aimed to promote China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and its potential benefits.
The content of the comic Book comic book portrayed China’s BRI positively, highlighting its potential to bring economic development and mutual benefits to participating countries.
However, the book also contained controversial elements, including perceived pro-China propaganda and criticism of Western countries, which were seen as promoting anti-China sentiments.
In Oct 2019, the Malaysian government, through the Home Affairs Ministry, banned the comic book.
The government stated that the book contained elements that could “endanger public order and security” and was seen as promoting a narrative that could influence Malaysian citizens, particularly students.
The government ordered the seizure of all copies of the comic book from schools, bookstores, and other outlets.
This was based on concerns that the book was being distributed in schools without proper approval from the Education Ministry, and the ban and seizure of the comic book were executed through administrative actions rather than through a judicial process.
The ban sparked a significant political debate in Malaysia. Some viewed the government’s actions as necessary to prevent foreign influence in Malaysia’s education system and to protect national interests. Others saw it as an overreaction and a suppression of freedom of expression.
The Home Ministry lifted the ban on Tuesday (Aug 13). The comic book was banned initially in Oct 2019 for allegedly promoting communism and socialism.
The question asked is whether individuals in Malaysia can pressure the government into reversing the move and if they can go against the court’s decision.
No institution is highly regarded in a country other than the judiciary which is the last refuge for Malaysians. Why then the hue and cry over the court’s decision? Compliance with court decisions is a fundamental aspect of the rule of law.
Politicians should not try to gain political milage by going against the court’s decision which may smear the image of the nation.
Let the current government move forward to bring the glory and glamour of the judiciary, the only refuge in Malaysia where Malaysians can turn to.
If the august institution come into ridicule or doubt then Malaysia will lose its international reputation and tarnish its image. – Aug 16, 2024
K.T. Maran is a Focus Malaysia reader.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Main image: The Star
