“Where’s your brain, Akmal? KLSCAH didn’t trade RM4.67m for RM1,000; it’s billions vs RM4.67m”

THE Kuala Lumpur Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (KLSCAH) was worth RM4.67 mil before institutional conversion – that’s the point rightist Datuk Dr Muhamad Akmal Saleh missed.

No wonder the World Bank data showed only about 58% of Malaysian kids proficient in reading by the end of Standard 5.

Your performance here is living proof that the problem did not stop at primary school. And no wonder Malaysia’s latest PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) test shows more than 65% are struggling with basic math (Level 2 or below).

With a UMNO Youth chief like you, we have a generation with problems not only in reading, but in basic calculation too.

‘National Heritage since 2007 under BN gov’t’

Nobody ever claimed there is a plot of land in KL with “no value”. People said the land has no commercial value – they never said the land has no value.

Can’t you tell the difference between the two? “Tiada nilai komersial” is not the same as “tiada nilai.”

Are you really this dumb or are you just acting dumb?

You invented that strawman yourself so you could look clever while missing the actual point. What people are saying – clearly, repeatedly – is that KLSCAH was valued at roughly RM4.67 mil before conversion to institutional use.

After the land status changed from commercial to institutional, the commercial development rights disappeared.

No more condo, no more shopping mall, no more high-rise profit. That is why the premium dropped to a nominal RM 1,000 for the 99-year lease.

Which part of “BEFORE institutionalisation versus AFTER” is still confusing you? Do we need to type it in simple MALAY for you?

Nilai tanah KLSCAH bernilai kira-kira RM4.67 juta sebelum ditukar kepada kegunaan institusi. Faham “SEBELUM”?

The building has stood since 1923 – older than you and your father or probably even your grandfather.

It was already gazetted as National Heritage in 2007 under a Barisan Nasional (BN) government.

The heritage restriction and the deliberate surrender of commercial rights are what destroyed the commercial valuation. That is not “free land with zero value.”

That is land that the owners themselves chose to lock into institutional/heritage use so the Chinese Assembly Hall can continue existing as a community and cultural institution instead of being flipped for profit.

 

View on Threads

 

Ignoring lucrative trade-off

Put it in the perspective you pretend to care about. If they had simply paid the RM4.67 mil and kept commercial title, they could have built a condominium or mixed development in the middle of KL and earned billions.

The Chinese Chamber is perfectly capable of paying RM4.67 mil. But they chose not to because they want the hall to remain a hall.

Once the status is institutional, the commercial upside is gone. That is the trade-off.

You are complaining that they accepted a lower premium in exchange for permanently giving up the right to make a fortune.

Is that what you actually want – for them to keep commercial rights and cash out? Let me spell out the math for you, Akmal because you clearly keep getting it backwards.

They are not trading RM4.67 mil for RM1,000. They are trading away the potential to earn billions in exchange for the RM4.67 mil they never had to pay.

That is the trade-off.

 

View on Threads

 

They gave up a potential fortune they could easily have pursued in return of keeping a heritage building as a community hall instead of a condominium showroom.

And since Akmal wants to bring PPR (People’s Housing Project), penjaja (traders), and bazar into a land-premium argument, let’s follow his logic to its natural conclusion.

KLSCAH got the near-total premium reduction because the land was gazetted into institutional/heritage use – the commercial development rights were legally extinguished and the premium was re-priced accordingly. That is the mechanism.

So if Akmal thinks that mechanism is scandalous, then presumably he wants the same treatment applied everywhere: gazette and institutionalise every single PPR block, every penjaja site, every bazar lot – strip their commercial status, kill their development upside and re-price them at nominal premium.

Is that the policy he is proposing?

And if the real issue in your head is that it is a Chinese organisation, then spare us the selective outrage.

Under the current administration (including the period with DAP in federal government), 50 acres of strategic land in KL was gazetted as Tanah Rizab Melayu/Bumiputera endowment valued at around RM1 bil.

That is roughly 200 times the RM4.67 mil figure you are clutching.

By your own logic of “how can they get this for so little,” the disparity is massive — yet somehow that does not trigger the same theatrical shock from you. – Nov 18, 2026

 

Phoenix Shen is a media personality, commentator and content creator who regularly provides political commentary, news breakdowns and social analysis on Malaysian politics.

The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.

Subscribe and get top news delivered to your Inbox everyday for FREE