Penang ANPR row resurfaces as MCA questions state’s review of parking system

THE Penang government must explain how it intends to address concerns raised over its Automated Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) parking enforcement system before considering its future use, said an MCA leader.

The party’s Penang State Liaison Committee Chairman Datuk Tan Teik Cheng questioned whether the review announced following public backlash against the system had adequately addressed motorists’ concerns, particularly over parking charges, enforcement and the handling of summonses.

His remarks came after Penang Local Government and Town and Country Planning Committee chairman H’ng Mooi Lye said the state had no immediate plans to resume ANPR enforcement, although the technology could be used for other purposes, including parking management and data collection.

Tan said the state government should publish the findings of its review and clarify what improvements had been made since the system’s enforcement function was suspended in August.

“Was the earlier review genuinely intended to listen to public concerns, or was it merely a publicity stunt to appease the people?” he asked.

The controversy arose after motorists raised concerns over the ANPR system, which was used by local council enforcement vehicles to scan vehicle registration plates and issue parking compounds when payment was not detected.

The system had drawn criticism over its short payment grace period and its treatment of motorists who remained inside their vehicles while occupying parking bays.

In August, Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow ordered the Penang Island City Council (MBPP) and Seberang Perai City Council (MBSP) to suspend ANPR-based parking enforcement pending a review, following public feedback.

Tan said MCA had welcomed the suspension at the time and called for a review of issues involving system integration, network disruptions, payment difficulties faced by senior citizens and tourists, as well as the appeals process for parking compounds.

He questioned whether those concerns had since been addressed.

“Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow had promised that necessary reviews would be conducted seriously and improvements made promptly. Yet, months have passed. Where are the findings, and what improvements have actually been made?” he asked.

Tan also criticised remarks concerning motorists who occupy parking bays while remaining inside their vehicles, saying the approach could place an unnecessary financial burden on the public.

“With the rising cost of living, the people are already struggling to make ends meet. Instead of easing their burden, the state government is now charging motorists even when they are merely waiting for someone,” he remarked.

He urged the state government to clarify how any future implementation of ANPR would distinguish between vehicles genuinely parked and those stopping briefly to pick up or drop off passengers.

Tan said authorities should also explain whether a grace period would be provided, how motorists would be protected from compounds arising from technical failures and what recourse would be available if payment systems were disrupted.

“We have never opposed the use of technology. However, technology has to be utilised to serve the people, not simply make it easier for the government to issue summonses,” he added.

While H’ng said on Friday that there were no immediate plans to resume ANPR enforcement, he indicated that the technology could still be considered for parking management, data collection or other applications in the future.

Tan urged the state government to make public the findings of its review, resolve outstanding concerns and consult motorists before introducing any new arrangements involving the technology.

“The people are not guinea pigs or the government’s cash machine. The government needs to stop ignoring their voices while claiming to put the people first,” he said. ‒ Nov 20, 2026

 

Main image: The Star

Subscribe and get top news delivered to your Inbox everyday for FREE